National vs. Local Policy Understanding

Challenge

From lending to insurance, and from permitting to appraisal, a disconnect between federal or corporate entities and their local agents often lead to discrepancies in understanding of rules and policies. This can lead to inconsistencies in practice and application between states, regions and localities.

Opportunity & Response

Working directly with partners across the spectrum of home procurement and through research contracts such as this Rural Studio provides a feedback conduit between on-the-ground agents and their organizations to identify unintended barriers to equitable housing access and affordability. As a State Research University, we have additionally leveraged the Intergovernmental Personnel Act (IPA) Mobility Program to embed federal employees more directly in the research.

Implementation

Chipola

Appraised Value

Challenge

Beyond-code building performance provides a demonstrated value-add that enhances home value. However due to the uneven nature of appraiser training and understanding of this increased value (particularly in rural areas where comparables may not yet exist), this increase in appraised value is not always realized.

Opportunity & Response

Equally critical to building high-performance homes is working with appraisers to ensure that the value of the performance features is incorporated into the assessed value of the home. Rural Studio currently works directly with local appraisers on a project-by-project basis to communicate this enhanced value. As our housing partner network continues to expand, it is increasingly necessary to provide informational resources for appraisers so that they value high-performance homes for their full worth.

Implementation

Stevens

Wharf

Integrating Construction and Financing

Challenge

In the traditional home procurement process “affordability” is a simple function of reducing what a home costs to build, with little-to-no consideration of what value and savings the integration of “beyond code” or “green” construction provides to the homeowner. Building to beyond code standards certainly increases the cost of home construction, but simultaneously provides month after month and year after year savings through a reduction in energy bills, insurance costs, and the like. There is currently no provision for how these post-occupancy monthly savings might be leveraged to reconsider the financing and monthly mortgage carry of the homeowner, and thus such upgrades are most often perceived of as unaffordable. 

Opportunity & Response

Some not-for-profit housing providers are set up to consider the total cost of homeownership. For example, since Habitat for Humanity is in control of the project financing (both construction financing and the mortgage for the homeowner), they are able to work in an integrated construction and finance model, considering building performance in the total cost of homeownership. Rural Studio provides up front predictive energy modeling, testing and verification during construction, and ongoing post-occupancy monitoring and homeowner education to ensure the high-performance capabilities of the homes are both met and maintained. Where housing partners are in control of both construction and financing, the information developed through this process increasingly allows our housing providers to integrate the high-performance savings into their overall housing finance and delivery strategy.

Implementation

Stevens

Local Lender/Borrower Relationships

Challenge

Some low-wealth borrowers do not meet traditional lending requirements because of a lower-than-allowed credit score, and traditional mortgage lenders understandably require potential borrowers to become “credit worthy” before they are considered for a mortgage. While a low credit score can indicate an unacceptable level of risk for a lender, it may also be reflective of a credit shortfall caused by collateral challenges due to the potential borrower being inadequately housed. While these are the potential homeowners that have the most to gain from the obligations of service by depository institutions, this gap between a buyer’s existing credit profile and a traditional lender’s ability assess risk based on the particular circumstances of that buyer is most often insurmountable.

Opportunity & Response

“Housing First” not-for-profits (NFPs) that work locally in the communities they serve have a better ability to consider the extenuating or mitigating circumstances of a specific borrower. For example, a mortgage candidate may have a low credit score because they are unbanked or underbanked. Local NFPs have the unique capacity to work with individuals on a case-by-case basis to first get them into secure housing and then spend time “seasoning up” the homeowner’s credit and financial literacy such that they can be transitioned to a more conventional mortgage product. There is a clear opportunity here for traditional lenders to partner with these NFPs strategically to develop a type of “step-up” program in which the NFP assumes the initial housing risk but leverages resources already developed by the lender to provide the necessary homeowner education and counseling to maintain lower than average delinquency rates.

Implementation

Myrtle

Stevens

Chipola

Constructability

Challenge

Due to the need for systems integration, the design and construction of kitchens and bathrooms require significant coordination.

Opportunity & Response

Standardizing layouts for bathrooms and kitchens leads to improved quality control, streamlined production, which make them more subcontractor and volunteer friendly to build.

Implementation

Standardization Worksheet

Tying Grant Funding to Performance

Challenge

With increasing frequency, grant agencies tie funding to beyond-code standards for energy and resilience.

Opportunity & Response

Front Porch Initiative is equipped to integrate a variety of beyond-code standards into the prototype homes. By understanding the performance requirements up front, we are able to coordinate details ahead of construction and mitigate any conflicts between requirements of multiple, occasionally conflicting, standards. We support integration of these high-performance standards, as they can reduce monthly energy and insurance costs.

Implementation

Chipola

Increasing Credit Capacity for Housing Providers

Challenge

For organizations that offer direct mortgages, such as Habitat for Humanity, increasing capacity can be a challenge.

Opportunity & Response

Not-for-profits can work with banks and financial institutions to increase their credit. For example, Regions Bank has extended a construction line of credit to Affordable Housing Resources to pay for construction of four homes. This loan will be repaid once AHR sells the homes. 

Regions Bank will receive CRA credit for financing the construction of the project, providing an incentive for this relationship.

Implementation

Chipola

Wharf

Variety of Funding Sources

Challenge

Organizations that rely on a single funding source may have trouble weathering a disruption in funding. 

Opportunity & Response

Expanding a housing provider’s capacity to draw from multiple funding avenues/ sources makes it more resilient as an organization, especially during challenging times.

Implementation

Chipola

Unaka

Wharf

Myrtle

Zoning & Parcel Size

Challenge

Residential zoning regulations serve a purpose of regulating sufficient access of dwellings to air, light, and fire protection. Zoning also allows communities to plan for adequate infrastructure and community facilities. However, zoning has also historically been used as a tool of exclusion, a means to “zone out” and disenfranchise certain populations and communities. The prints of this history are still visible in communities today. In one example, it has been found that lot sizes in a historically Black neighborhood are smaller than lots in other parts of town. With modern lot coverage and floor area ratios, it can be challenging to develop these smaller parcels without combining multiple parcels. This further disenfranchises certain, targeted, areas of cities by reducing the number of citizens living in these areas. 

Opportunity & Response

The smaller footprint of the Product Line Homes allows them to fit on smaller parcels, maintaining a higher number of housing units and, therefore, a higher number of homeownership opportunities within the community. Increasing homeownership opportunity has proven to increased access, increases the tax base, and increases community participation, engagement, and investment. Perhaps more importantly, research shows that the impact on civic engagement and investment is greatest for low- and mid-income homeowners.

Implementation

Stevens Street

Chipola

Unaka

Joint Center

HUD

Urban Affairs Institute

Zoning for Small Homes

Challenge

Zoning codes in some areas place a minimum square footage requirement on lots. This can discourage the construction of small homes.

Opportunity & Response

Some cities, such as the City of Nashville, have implemented progressive zoning ordinances that accommodate a wider variety of development types. For example, Nashville’s R6 zoning allows for a “detached duplex” configuration in which two homes, each with a separate owner, can be constructed on one lot (without subdividing the lot). Two Rural Studio homes easily fit on Nashville’s typical narrow, deep lots.

Other common examples of zoning that accommodates small homes are the allowance of accessory dwelling units (ADUs) and Planned Unit Developments (PUDs).

Implementation

Wharf Ave.

Air Serenbe